5 Common DUI Mistakes to Avoid in Colorado Springs

by | Jul 14, 2025 | DUI Defense

The DUI mistakes to avoid can begin the second you see flashing lights in your rearview mirror, and what follows can feel like your world is suddenly spinning out of control. A DUI charge in Colorado Springs brings fear, uncertainty, and stress—emotions that often lead to costly missteps with long-term consequences. Many El Paso County residents are unaware that the choices they make in the hours, days, and weeks following an arrest can significantly impact the outcome of their case.

The Hidden Consequences of a DUI in Colorado Springs

In Colorado Springs, a DUI conviction means more than just legal penalties. It affects your ability to drive, maintain your independence, and navigate daily life in a city where public transportation options are limited. Your personal relationships, career opportunities, and financial stability all hang in the balance when facing DUI charges in El Paso County.

Knowing what DUI mistakes to avoid can help protect these critical aspects of your life.

Common DUI Mistakes to Avoid During Your Stop

As mentioned above, from the moment you see a police cruiser behind you, you need to start making good choices to protect your future. And to make good choices, you need to understand the most common DUI mistakes to avoid during your stop.

Speaking Too Much to Law Enforcement

One of the most common DUI mistakes to avoid when stopped by law enforcement officers in Colorado Springs is thinking that you can talk your way out of trouble.

However, remember that excessive explanation can lead to self-incrimination.

The more you speak, the more potential evidence you provide. Even innocent comments about “just having one beer” can be used against you in court.

Instead, exercise your right to remain silent. Politely provide your identification and basic information, but state clearly that you want to speak with a lawyer before answering questions about where you’ve been or what you’ve consumed.

Statements made to officers during a DUI stop are among the most damaging pieces of evidence in court proceedings. Your words carry significant weight and can be difficult to explain away later.

Refusing or Misunderstanding Chemical Tests

The following DUI mistakes to avoid involve refusing a chemical test. Colorado’s Express Consent Law creates a complicated situation when you’re asked to take a breath or blood test.

  • Understanding the consequences of refusal: Refusing a chemical test triggers an automatic one-year license suspension, regardless of whether you were actually impaired. This penalty applies even if the DUI charges are later dismissed or dropped.
  • Know your testing options: You can request a blood test instead of a breath test, which can give your attorney additional ways to challenge the evidence against you. The testing facility also matters—results from some facilities may be more vulnerable to challenge than those from others.

The Colorado Department of Transportation reports that test refusals lead to harsher penalties compared to failed tests. Avoiding DUI mistakes related to chemical testing can prevent severe consequences to your driving privileges.

Newby - DUI Mistakes to Avoid

DUI Mistakes to Avoid Post-Arrest

Once you have been formally charged with drunk driving in Colorado Springs, knowing the DUI mistakes to avoid becomes even more imperative.

After a DUI arrest in Colorado Springs, time is not on your side.

  • Critical early deadlines approach quickly: You have only 7 days from your arrest to request a DMV hearing to protect your driving privileges. Miss this deadline, and your license is automatically suspended.
  • Evidence preservation requires prompt action: Security camera footage that might show you were driving normally could be deleted within days. Witnesses’ memories fade quickly, and weather conditions that might have affected field sobriety tests won’t be documented without quick attorney intervention.

Your Colorado Springs drunk driving attorney needs time to investigate the specific location of your stop, whether it was a legitimate checkpoint operation or a questionable stop. One of the most essential DUI mistakes to avoid is failing to secure experienced legal representation to start working on your defense immediately.

Related: What Are Your Rights at a DUI Checkpoint in Colorado Springs?

Ignoring the DMV Proceedings

One of the biggest and most common DUI mistakes to avoid is focusing your time and attention on the criminal charges you are facing and neglecting the separate administrative process with the DMV.

  • Two separate cases require attention: Your DUI arrest triggers both a criminal case in El Paso County Court and an administrative case with the Colorado DMV. Losing either case results in serious consequences.
  • DMV hearings provide strategic advantages: At these hearings, your attorney can cross-examine the arresting officer under oath before your criminal trial begins, potentially revealing inconsistencies or procedural errors that can help your criminal case.

The DMV hearing is your only chance to prevent automatic license suspension while your case proceeds. You need an attorney who will prioritize defending you during both the criminal and administrative stages of your case.

Taking a Plea Deal Without Professional Analysis

DUI mistakes to avoid include accepting a plea bargain from the El Paso County District Attorney’s office without consulting a lawyer. The fact is that prosecutors are not on your side. They may be offering you a deal that may seem attractive when you’re feeling desperate, but may not be in your best interests.

  • Standard offers aren’t always your best option: What seems like a “good deal” might have hidden consequences for your specific situation, including impacts on your career, professional licenses, or security clearances.
  • Every case has unique factors: The specific location of your stop, the officer’s training, the maintenance records of testing equipment, and dozens of other factors can create defense opportunities that generic plea offers don’t account for.

Former prosecutors understand precisely how the El Paso County DA’s office evaluates cases and know where the weaknesses might be in yours. A crucial part of knowing what DUI mistakes to avoid is having qualified legal counsel evaluate any plea offers before accepting them.

Newby - DUI Mistakes to Avoid

Protect Your Rights and Your Future

Remember that a DUI charge is not the same as a conviction. With proper legal representation focusing on the unique aspects of your case, you can achieve a much better outcome than you expect. Knowing just what DUI mistakes to avoid is the first step toward a successful defense.

Don’t let a single error turn into multiple problems that compound your situation. The actions you take today will determine whether this incident becomes a life-altering conviction or a challenging but manageable legal situation.

Your Best Strategy for Avoiding DUI Mistakes in Colorado Springs

When facing DUI charges in Colorado Springs, you need more than just legal representation—you need someone who understands the local court system from the inside.

At Newby Lindley Slater, we leverage our experience as former DUI prosecutors to work in the best interest of our clients. We know precisely how the El Paso County District Attorney builds DUI cases and where to look for weaknesses. We ensure that you do not fall victim to these common DUI mistakes that can harm your defense and your future.

Schedule your free, confidential consultation with Newby Lindley Slater now and take the first step toward regaining control of your situation. The sooner you reach out, the more options we’ll have to fight for your rights, your license, and your future. Don’t wait another day to get the skilled representation you deserve.

James Newby

James Newby is a criminal defense attorney in Colorado Springs and the managing attorney of the criminal justice law firm Newby Lindley Slater. James got into law because of a deep-rooted passion for helping good people that may have made a poor choice that could have lasting consequences.